Steadman.

Eight famous findings, re-tested

On Monday night I re-tested eight well-known findings on newer public data, the Ethan Mollick way: extend a famous result to new years and places, and see if it still holds. Before any outcome data was touched, I wrote down what I would measure and what would change my mind. Each result was then checked independently.

Of the eight, one clearly holds, two are weaker or mixed, one fails, and four can't tell either way with the data available.

1. Do violent films reduce violent crime? Fails
Infographic: Do violent films reduce violent crime? Verdict: Fails.
2. Do upset football losses raise domestic violence? Can't tell
Infographic: Do upset football losses raise domestic violence? Verdict: Can't tell.
3. Do TV characters shape baby names? Weaker
Infographic: Do TV characters shape baby names? Verdict: Weaker.
4. Are pop songs getting shorter, sadder and more repetitive? Mixed
Infographic: Are pop songs getting shorter, sadder and more repetitive? Verdict: Mixed.
5. Did youth suicide rise after 13 Reasons Why? Holds
Infographic: Did youth suicide rise after 13 Reasons Why? Verdict: Holds.
6. Does air pollution make chess players err? Can't tell
Infographic: Does air pollution make chess players err? Verdict: Can't tell.
7. Does the clock change cause fatal crashes? Can't tell
Infographic: Does the clock change cause fatal crashes? Verdict: Can't tell.
8. Do World Cup losses move stock markets? Can't tell
Infographic: Do World Cup losses move stock markets? Verdict: Can't tell.

These re-tests use public data and have not yet been reviewed by a qualified researcher. Treat each verdict as a first look, not a final word. From David's Saturday AI Thoughts, Edition 37.